Is It a Bird? Is It a Plane? No, it's a Drone.
In this episode of the Good Disruption podcast, Mike Lenox and Yael Grushka-Cockayne talk with Mark Hahn (MBA ’20) a career Naval Aviator and previous operations lead for drone start-up company Zipline about the UAV landscape and the pros and cons of using this technology.
00:00 / 34:20
Imagine ordering food from Door Dash and it’s delivered to your doorstep within minutes, not by a driver, but a drone. For residents in Dallas-Fort Worth suburbs, this became reality this past summer. And customer delivery isn’t the only industry being disrupted by drones. From precision agriculture to precision battlefield strikes, the use of unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) is changing the game.
Mike and Yael talk with Mark Hahn (MBA ’20) a career Naval Aviator and previous operations lead for drone start-up company Zipline about the UAV landscape and the pros and cons of using this technology.
For more episodes, visit: https://gooddisruption.podbean.com/
Transcript
UVA Darden.
The Disruption, a lively discussion between UVA Darden School of Business professors Yael Grushka Cocaine and Mike Lennox on cutting edge technologies and practices that are challenging the status quo.
Hello Yael.
Hey, how are you, Mike?
How are you doing on this fall day?
I am doing great.
My, you know, one of my two favorite seasons of the year.
Oh, what's your other favorite season?
Spring, obviously not summer.
No, definitely not summer.
I, I'm a spring person.
I, I do actually like maybe all three seasons, but summer because I really like the heat.
Yeah, OK.
And my wife and I have this debate all the time.
We're actually summer people.
We love going to the beach and the ocean and everything.
The winter, winters always last.
I love the winter.
Do you love it?
Do you ski?
Nope, I don't, but I like cuddling on the sofa with a high, you know, hot cup of coffee.
Do you like our winters where we get like two, you know, snowstorms per year in Charlottesville?
OK, OK, that's good.
That's good.
I, I like winter up until like New Year's, and then, and then I'm done with, then you're done with it.
Yeah.
One of the great things here in Charlottesville, Virginia, and Central Virginia is we tend to get spring like the beginning of March, so it kind of is nice.
We actually have 4.
Seasons and they're all pretty equally sized so I think we're pretty lucky.
We are.
I lived in Boston for a while and you know the joke there was there was no spring.
It just went right into winter.
I lived in London for 7 years and it's just rainy seasons there.
Oh, rain, rain, and more rain.
Yeah, well, hey, while, while we're on the topic of favorite seasons, uh, when you were a child in the summertime, maybe the spring or the fall, did you ever have a, a flying toy of some sort?
Good question.
What, like one of those like remote control kind of, exactly, yeah, yeah, uh, we had our, it was a lot of fun, or I don't know.
I think I preferred the more static toys, but yes, we had our fair share.
Well, I don't know about, you know, I, I don't know if I really had many when I was growing up other than like a kite.
It is the extent of the technology, but I do remember with my kids when they were younger.
My kids are, as you know, older now, um, I felt like we bought them drones for like 3 years running, and it was the best. 24 hours before it would completely either be destroyed or run into a tree.
I got one for my son one year for the holidays, and I think the drone is still sitting in our closet somewhere, um, and my, my husband likes, um, he used to do a lot of paper airplanes when he was young, um, so he and his dad used to do a lot of that.
So I think that he was hoping that he and my son would.
Engage in that, but it didn't really live that long, you know, last that long.
Well, the, the reason I wanted to ask this is because I want to talk about drones today.
Yes, yes, great topic.
I've just been watching two episodes of Ozark where drones play a pretty big role in Ozarks.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
So, so let me start with asking a question.
This is kind of my cold call question for you.
What, what is a drone?
Oh, do you imagine?
An unmanned aerial vehicle.
Oh, that's excellent.
You did your homework.
You knew this coming in.
Yeah, um, ironically, like, uh, this is not, uh, you know, as it's not that unusual in this conversation that we have in our show that the technology itself is not all that new.
So ones have been around for a while.
Well, in fact, all the way back to 1918, none other than Orville Wright of the Wright brothers, inventors of air, uh, travel.
If you will, uh, they had something called the Kittering bug.
It was Oval Wright and Charles Kittering, uh, in 1918 as the first UAV.
So what they were thinking the use case would be then, because it probably has changed quite a bit in terms of, you know today's use case for drones.
I'm not sure, but you know, you could imagine it might even been similar in terms of like deliveries and the like there.
I think one of the important distinctions we need to make right away is that these UAVs, these drones, they're.
There are kind of two flavors of them, and the second flavor I'll mention is kind of growing in importance.
So the first is unmanned but often controlled by a human directly, and I think that's what most of the drones that we've seen in our own lives and experience are of that type.
They have some kind of remote control, some kind of device, or maybe your phone these days where you can actually guide this, you know, toy to throw it around, fly around.
You can control its height.
You can control where it goes.
Yeah, but to be clear, we're gonna talk more about this, you know, some of these toys like those being deployed by the military, there might be somebody sitting here in central Virginia, you know, controlling a drone halfway around the world, right, um, but the second type of drone, if you will, are those that are becoming increasingly autonomous.
And so we've talked about AI repeatedly on this podcast.
AI is coming in this world as well, um, so we're seeing more and more of these more autonomous drones.
That are able to function without the human controller as well come out and that seems like a natural combination or extension if you will of what we talked about in terms of cars, right?
So you had your autonomous vehicles and why not have autonomous aerial devices and airplanes and the like.
So you know we talk a lot about S curves and you know if you go back to 1918 to where we are today, you know, this has been a long S curve with this technology, um, but it does.
Feel like we're at this inflection point in terms of the improvement.
So just give you some examples here.
Um, you might remember like when our kids had drones, I don't know about you, it'd be like 20 minutes of entertainment and then you'd have to charge it up again, battery life.
So now with the extended batteries that we have today, uh, over 4 hours, you know, depending on the use case and the like that you might get out of your drone, uh, distance as a result, much, much further, uh, and, and related to that, depending if it's a Uh, you know, remote controlled drone, um, utilizing 5G networks and the like, so you can go very far because it also used to be the case, and I think that's why they only lasted 24 hours at my home, is if it got too far away, you'd lose control and crash into a tree, uh, or the like.
Um, they're also being fitted with more cutting edge sensors and cameras now, including thermal and LDA, uh, and all of these sophisticated ways to map your world here.
So what they, you know.
Can do for us and what they can show us is becoming more and more sophisticated there.
And then the last piece I would add, and this fits into a kind of our AI integration piece here, we're thinking of ways in which we deploy multiple drones in concert with one another.
So have you ever seen one of these drone light shows?
No, yes, I have.
I think we, uh, maybe you saw here at New Year's at UVA.
There was a beautiful, beautiful one.
I miss, I missed that.
The, the other one, and this.
It will be funny for anyone who lives in Charlottesville.
There's something called the Winter Wander that they run at the Boarside Bay resort, and now they have a drone show.
So if you've ever seen one of these, you know, literally thousands of drones working in concert with one another to form objects in the sky, I mean, it's quite amazing compared to, again, what we were used to growing up with like fireworks displays and the like.
And just, uh, just again going back to your initial idea around like definitions here, so.
When does a drone no longer become a drone, but you're talking about like autopilot kind of flying a plane.
Like how do we distinguish between them?
Does the fact that there are no humans on it, or is there another way to think about it?
Yeah, and I think I'll, I'll give you an example where it's getting even more conflated here.
So I think in general the definition would be there's no human on board.
However, there are entrepreneurs in Silicon Valley, as they always are, who are working on quadcopters, which is often what.
Popular imagination of what a drone is these days, where you have like 4 helicopter blades to kind of give you the lift, um, that they're building much larger to transport humans.
But to be clear, they're still unmanned in that you as the person in the quadcopter are not actually controlling it.
Um, lots of interesting questions of whether you would trust an unmanned vehicle that is flying, uh, to take you from point A to point B.
But as we've talked on this podcast before, lots of people are doing this on automobiles now with Waymo and Tesla and others offering AV, uh, services.
Would, would you ever do that, you think?
Would you ever go?
Oh, I don't know.
I'm still debating, you know, Waymo's coming to DC very shortly, and I'm still on the fence.
I think that people have convinced me that it's pretty safe these days and probably safer than most cars.
You must be a pretty comfortable flyer, I'm imagining.
Pretty comfortable, yeah, yeah, comfortable.
I've gotten, I think, less comfortable as I've grown older, but generally, yeah.
Yeah, it's kind of the maternal kind of instinctt kicks in a little bit there.
I get that.
I get that, you know, I'm, I'm one who can like fall asleep in the worst of turbo.
Oh really?
Yeah, I don't know.
It used to be better, but I'm no longer, yeah, I can usually do pretty well.
Even saying that, I'm not sure if I'm ready to get into an unmanned quadcopter, uh, to take me off.
Well, you know, this is obviously a podcast often focused on markets.
So let's put some numbers to what's happening here, and I have some follow-up questions.
Sure.
So, uh, most recent year, the market was valued at about 42. $6 billion so US dollars, so that's a fairly large size, but it's projected to grow to about $122 billion by 2032.
So we're talking about 12.5, uh, 14%, uh, growth rate, uh, over the next few years compounded on the growth rate here.
And is it mostly, um, the use case, is it mostly growth around the delivery services, the Amazons of the world?
Oh, I'm so glad you asked that.
So I think many of us kind of common citizens think about the idea of delivery, and that is something we want to talk.
About here, but it's far more, uh, diverse than that.
Um, so clearly there's a whole military application and there's, you know, numerous companies rising to, you know, deploy drones, uh, at scale for for warfare, and we should talk more about that.
And it's actually already changing warfare as we know, dramatically changing warfare.
Uh, the second is areas like, uh, agriculture, um, and what we might call precision agriculture, using the drones, uh, for information purposes.
Uh, and then sometimes for delivery of like seeds and for, uh, water, um, and to really improve the efficacy of agriculture.
So that that's been a big, uh, big change.
What about, uh, supervising and watching over the animals and kind of providing some additional services, exactly, just that, that information that you can collect from up in the air versus on the ground.
There was an interesting article recently, I think it was in the Wall Street Journal, talking about.
Uh, migration of, uh, antelope in Africa that had never really been fully tracked because it was just nearly impossible to do so, uh, and they deployed drones that then I think autonomously was counting the number of animals.
And so again, there's some really interesting, you know, use cases for even science, um, that we're seeing here.
Although having, uh, spent a couple of weeks in the summer in Tanzania in the Serengeti, I'm very glad that I didn't have to hear drones hanging over me when I was in the middle of the Serengeti and I could only.
Watch the migration.
Well, and this, and this is one of the things, you know, we, we definitely want to talk about as we consider good, bad, or no disruption here is, you know, what are some of the downsides.
So you, you mentioned one which is, is noise.
I had a similar experience.
We were actually at the beach, uh, sitting there, you know, a beautiful sunset over the sound, and all of a sudden and like it was only like 30 ft above me.
Some a neighbor, I assume had pulled out their drone to take a picture of the sunset, and it was.
Yeah, it was a little bit of a buzz kill, a little bit of a buzz kill.
Um, I think another big one, especially with, with private use of these drones is, is privacy, um, because these could be flying over your home.
There are various rules and regulations being put in place, but as you can imagine, this is very hard to, uh, to manage and regulate.
What about the FAA and how do they feel or any airspace controller, how do they feel about the invasion and sharing the airspace until now?
Now it's been pretty limited to to what they regulate and allow.
So how do they feel about, yeah, and I think this is, this is a huge issues in the sky that needs to be resolved, and there's been progress and there's still more progress that needs to be made on what is allowed and not allowed.
Clearly we've restricted the use of these around certain sensitive areas, including, of course, airports, uh, but also military installations and the like.
Um, but they've had any number of instances where drones have been found like going over sensitive military areas.
Uh, um, I imagine there are companies who have to worry about this of going over sensitive, you know, private areas that they have.
And so, uh, this management of drones is, you know, clearly a huge issue.
Well, let's, let's talk quickly about some of the sectors.
OK, good.
And I, and also I'm, I'm keen to hear like where do you think the Exciting use of drones is coming from.
Like what, what, what can we look forward to?
Well, so first, let's talk about military, uh, you know, just dramatically has changed the nature of warfare.
Their deployment, especially in the Ukraine war, has been, um, game changing, I think it's fair to say the Middle East as well, yeah, and I think, you know, that that has a lot of concerns about, um, again, how easy it is to engage in war, uh, and As I've heard some of the military say, you know, the age of big metal like where we have big tanks and big aircraft carriers, uh, might be rendered moot by, by drones who can, you know, at scale swarm, and my understanding in Ukraine, you know, these are just commercial, uh, drones that you could, you know, buy for your kids that they're redeploying to be used as military vehicles that really kind of is a pretty bleak and scary in the sense that.
It implies that somebody can engage in warfare without having as much at stake, uh, in some ways, and that's, that's, that's dangerous.
Like I can see that that's a slippery slope, yeah, and I want to get back to this, and we're gonna be bringing our expert in here in a little while.
I want to talk about that, that, yeah, uh, but let's talk a little bit again about agriculture, again, everything from crop monitoring, livestock monitoring, even crop spraying that could be done there.
So again, these are finding heavy deployment there.
And then let's talk about the third one, which I think is the one maybe the most fun for people, which is commercial delivery.
Um, so way back in 2013, almost over a decade ago, Amazon with Jeff Bezos on 60 Minutes, the television show, famously released this video of drone delivery.
And, and again, it's often with technologies we've talked about, it was a little ahead of its time.
Like I think all of us were thinking, oh, this is coming next week, and like.
No, but a decade later, it is coming and it is being deployed.
So just some examples here, uh, in Australia, uh, DoorDash has been using drones for several years now to get out to rural areas.
Uh, China, maybe not surprising, has been a heavy adopter of these, using it for a variety of different, uh, areas. it is in the US and in the US we're beginning to see some experiments now in California, and Texas, and Arizona, um, so the FAA.
Has given some permission to operate these drones beyond the pilot's line of sight.
So again, this idea that they can go much further using the sensors to tell them where they are.
Uh, some of these are with, uh, Walmart, uh, DoorDash, uh, one of the big companies that's kind of interesting, uh, entering the space is Zipline, which has this cool technology where instead of landing the drone to deliver the package, it stays high up and then has a zip line that drops the zip line that drops the.
Or slowly I guess puts the package down on the ground for you.
Um, so again, I wouldn't say this is obviously at scale, but there are commercially viable, uh, models now being brought to the market of, uh, of drone delivery.
So if I'm, uh, in the midst of cooking and I realize that I'm, uh, you know, out of eggs, I can then hop on to Walmart's website and, uh, order a drone to deliver me the eggs, maybe, depending on where you are you one of these pilot areas.
Make it to my house.
Yeah.
Well, and one of the, I think, I think the answer is yes from a technological standpoint, but as often with new technology, the underlying economics, right, like when does it make sense to do this and when is this, you know, yeah, it doesn't make sense for your eggs to be delivered via drone, um, or maybe I'll pay a premium, a high premium in order to cover the additional delivery cost.
Maybe exactly, exactly, and I think those are the types of dynamics that are gonna need to be worked out.
You think it's time to bring in our expert?
Yes, I have many, many more.
I was gonna say I definitely think it's time to bring in our expert.
I, that was about it.
That's all I got on my, uh, on my knowledge on drones.
Well, we're really excited to have with us, uh, Mark Hahn.
Uh, Mark is, uh, majority of his career has been as a naval aviator flying aircraft carrier based tactic. jets.
So this is, so he knows something he knows manned aviation, but he also knows some things about, uh, other, you know, ways in which we can deploy in the military.
In particular, he's earned multiple air medals for combat operations over Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria.
He's provided electronic attack support for allied ground forces, and then he pivoted, um, as we often see, he came to Darden, got his MBA back in 2020.
Uh, and joined Zipline, the company I was just mentioning there, based out of San Francisco.
Uh, he held, has held several roles there, primarily engineering program management and leading global operations strategy and planning.
Um, so he, he knows it both from the military side but also from the commercial side.
So, we, we are so excited to have you, uh, with us here today, Mark.
Well, thanks for having me.
Excited to be here.
It's nice to meet you, Mark, and thank you for taking the time.
What, how lucky are we that we have such an expert in our community.
Absolutely, absolutely.
So, so, Mark, let, let's start maybe with the military side of things here.
Can you tell us a little bit just where is the state of warfare using drones, and I know it's a fast moving, you know, space here, uh, but, but what, what's your general sense of it?
You mentioned the war in Ukraine.
I mean, we're seeing.
The, you know, drones basically taking over the battlefield strategy there and, um, and as you also mentioned, these are not like, uh, what we're typically used to seeing in the military industrial complex in the US.
So they're not multi-million dollar drones.
These are, uh, drones that cost, you know, on the order of hundreds of dollars to to build.
So, therefore, like, you know, you're seeing proliferation.
The ability to deploy these things at scales that really haven't been seen before, I would say, in, um, you know, in conventional warfare for the amount of, uh, for the amount of range and the amount of capabilities that they actually have.
I think it really turned a lot of people in the military, kind of opened their eyes to a completely new dynamic on um on the battlefield and something that We're going to have to adjust to.
We've seen it in, you know, in Ukraine that Our current systems, uh, both offensive and defensive, but, um, Mainly on the, I think the defensive front.
Aren't really designed for that kind of warfare.
I mean, we're utilizing Patriot missile batteries to shoot down, um, you know, $100 drones, and it's just, um, it's unsustainable in the long term if, uh, if it continues to go in that route.
So I think like, I think the military is scrambling right now to um to catch our.
Own capabilities up to um what we're seeing being employed in uh in Ukraine, but from um the ability to deploy them ourselves as well as the ability to defend them in a manner that scales and is not cost prohibitive.
Yeah, I'm, I'm curious, you know, as a, as a former jet pilot, uh, in the Navy, um, and as most Americans, my whole knowledge of this world is the, I know, but in the Top Gun Maverick, obviously one of the themes, if you will, or underlying currents was the idea that the, the age of the fighter jet pilot.
Is gonna go away, uh, and, and all we're gonna have is, uh, autonomous vehicles, autonomous drones, and the like.
What what are your thoughts on that?
Is, is the age of the fighter pilot, you know, done with this, or are we gonna see more, uh, need, still have need, I guess, for the fighter pilot?
Well, I should, I should also, uh, before I answer this question, I should.
Let you know that I, you know, I would jokingly be considered a traitor by many of my former colleagues by going to the unmanned, um, unmanned drone, uh, excuse me, unmanned aircraft, uh.
Sector, but, um, you know, and unfortunately, and I say unfortunately because it is um I, I have such fond memories of that time in my life, um, and it is what I would, what I, for me it was the best career in the world, um.
Yeah, unfortunately, I do think it is, there's an end in sight to it, and the reason for that is that um the capability of drones to operate in um in the areas we want to, and the ease of deployment is much uh much easier and then um be more on a technological, uh.
Aspect.
The things you need to do to put a person in an aircraft increase both the complexity of the uh the systems involved.
You have to have, um, you know, ejection seats, displays, readouts, space for the person, uh, on board oxygen, climate control systems, things like that.
Uh, which ultimately increases the cost of those, uh, of those aircraft, um, as well as, uh, The radar cross section is another big is another big thing.
So, the bigger something is, the farther away it can be seen by radar systems um is is a major factor in military planning, so.
Um, as, as much as I hate to say it, I, I do think that, you know, we're looking at the, the probably the last generation of manned tactical aviation, I would say.
Fascinating.
I mean, it's uh fascinating to think of the world, um, uh, of that future world, uh, knowing I rest assured or have some confidence in humankind that we also come up, can come up with a defense, the like the counter argument which is, OK, we'll figure out how to defend ourselves from drones too, like if we're gonna substitute aircraft, uh.
By optimistic, but, but back to that.
I actually wanna pivot and maybe say maybe take a step back and kind of get a more um positive or, uh, expand the use cases beyond the military kind of purpose.
What about, um, Mark?
Are you seeing or is Zipline engaged in, and maybe it's not Zipline specifically, but the industry.
Are we talking about now reaching every part of the world, like people who are suffering or sometimes we have, you know, people that are lost in, in various like accidents and so on.
Like, is this changing the way that we can help humankind?
Can we, can we get medical equipment to, you know, remote locations?
Like I'm thinking about all the things that we've been typically limited by.
I feel like drones should make the world a smaller place as opposed to, uh, anything else, right?
Well, Mark, if I understand that, that's zipline story, right?
How did that zip line get its start?
All right, uh, I, I need to, I, this is an important clarification that I think is often missed because Zipline does have a great story, but Zipline, um, you know, a lot of people do talk about that, and Zipline is doing amazing things in Africa with their drone, you know, their drone delivery.
They've reduced, um, with their blood delivery systems they set up in Rwanda and Ghana.
Those were the first two countries we served in Africa.
Um, they've reduced postpartum hemorrhaging by over 50% in both locations at the places they surf.
So there are plenty of people walking around on this earth today because of that technology, which is, you know, which is absolutely fantastic.
The zipline gets a lot of credit for being, um, you know, this organization that's, you know, delivering medicine to Rwanda and Ghana.
Um, an inside story from Zipline and, uh, you know, the founders have actually said this, so it's not any particular secret or anything, but Zipline actually started, the founders of Zipline started Zipline, not, not, it wasn't called Zipline at the time, but they originally set out to build a children's robotic toy, and that failed.
And then they pivoted to drone delivery.
So the idea that a group of people got together in a room and said like, let's, you know, let's really fix this problem of postpartum hemorrhaging in sub-Saharan Africa is that's not exactly how it happened.
It happened, um, you know, it, it did happen after zipline was founded and, you know, they transitioned to drones, and that actually You know, that that became a critical part of Zipline's history because through, um, you know, people are more willing to bend aviation rules if you're saying, hey, we're, we need this, you know, this authorization or we need this restriction lifted in order to fly these drones to save people, rather than like, Hey, we, we need this restriction lifted or we need a little wiggle room on, you know, on these, uh, these rules in order to deliver somebody a burrito, you know, so, well, but this is, but look, that's, that's very common for entrepreneurial stories is that you start with one thing and then you pivot and then you discover an opportunity or a challenge that you could solve and then you go off to it.
So I, you know, I, I think that's, that's a great story actually, because I think we see that quite a bit.
Uh, with, with ventures.
How, how about on the, on the commercial side?
How are things, you know, shaping, as I mentioned, yeah, my impression is there are obviously a lot of these efforts out there by commercial, uh, entities.
Um, how, how, how profitable, how, how extensive, you know, does this, this model work at this point?
You know, zip line's natural, uh, you know, since we just spoke about kind of like the blood delivery and the vaccine delivery, um, you know, that, that works really, really well in, you know, in, uh, in Africa and hard to access, access spaces, um, but ultimately, the company.
Does, you know, has their sights on the, you know, commercial drone delivery in the United States, and that is not necessarily blood deliveries, that's, um, you know, that's, you know, delivering those, you know, burritos and coffee and, um, you know, Tylenol and, you know, uh, things like that, um.
And, you know, there's, there is, there is certainly a possibility for that, and I think there's a lot of benefits in, you know, in doing that.
You, you lose, you know, some of those like social good benefits, but, um, you know, there's uh There are very many um reasons why drone drone delivery makes sense in, you know, in the US and that is, you know, having a car deliver.
Uh, again, I, I keep on using the term or the example of a burrito, but it works pretty well.
And Zipline recently signed a partnership with Chipotle, so, uh, burritos, I suppose, have been on my mind.
But, but anyway, you think about a, a driver delivering a burrito, and it just is an incredibly inefficient means to get a burrito from, um, the point of origin to the delivery point, you know, driving a 3000 pound car, um.
You know, so I think the gains you see in um in being a carbon reduction in less wear and tear on infrastructure in um In reduction in traffic, uh, that, you know, those are, those are real, real gains to be made and, you know, really, uh, um, and, you know, in the speed at which, you know, you're going to get it is, is going to be, um, you know, theoretically multiples faster.
So, uh, I think.
You know, I think it certainly does make sense, um, in, you know, in the US and other, other parts of the world for, uh, to implement, you know, a drone system, um, you know, with that there certainly come challenges.
Uh, however, I, I, I, I like this because, you know, both of us, y'all and I have an operations background and, um, you know, the traveling salesperson problem, um, which is how do you effectively deliver a set of goods to, uh, especially a dense network of delivery points.
And it just makes so much sense to me that you would actually wanna mix, right?
There might be homes in a more densely packed area where that truck delivery makes 100%, you know, sense.
But then that person who lives a little further out, I think here in Charlottesville is a great example where we have some density, but we also have some rural areas very close by.
You know, optimizing that system is, is good, like you said, for infrastructure for the environment, uh, and the like.
Although it's interesting because, um, I can imagine the, the next generation of models where it's like because now you have to think of uh one drone that can carry less and how, you know, or multiple drones going in different destinations and we're gonna have to do the traveling drone, you know, uh, uh, kind of professors in business though, right, you know, trying to solve those conflicts.
I, I, um, we often ask on this, uh, show, uh, Mark, like.
What has changed?
Why now?
And maybe this is not just now.
Maybe we've seen this on a steady increase, uh, maybe it's been kind of pretty constant and linear in fashion, or maybe we've seen some kind of, uh, huge growth recently.
Like, is there something, is it the AI with the battery with the kind of additional sensoring?
Is there other things going on in terms of the innovation here and the technology that is changing that is allowing drones to become a real kind of, uh, uh, viable business model?
Yeah, um, I mean, that's, that's a good question.
I think like the You know, a part of it certainly is technology, you know, 2020 years ago, you would have had to have, uh, you know, I think.
You would have certainly had to have 1 to 1 controller, meaning like you have one person controlling one drone, uh, in order to do that, uh, in order to actually like fly a drone around, um, and, um, and make a delivery, even if you were able to do that 20 years ago.
Um, you know, nowadays, the autonomy function of the drone, I think is really where The scale and the um the advantage, you know, the advantage lies there, cause, you know, drones, drones share a lot of things with, you know, a delivery van, they share a lot of, you know, maintenance, uh, you know, upkeep, um, you know, so, you know, there, there certainly is that, and then um.
You know, I think the other thing is kind of like the, the introduction of the um.
The Uber Eats DoorDash model was another pivotal point in the um.
In kind of realizing that, you know, drones were going to be uh.
The future or, you know, could be the future here and um the validation, you know, the validation of that model basically kind of, you know, set the blueprint for, you know, for the, you know, for the business.
So um.
It's, uh, you know, not, not exactly the same, but understanding that the uh consumer's expectations now for delivery is, it's almost immediate, you know, the Amazon, I think I read something.
A little while ago that said like, we, we, you know, we used to think of Amazon Prime's 2 day shipping as being like, wow, that's amazing, but you know, Amazon now, they say like over 80% of their packages are delivered same day or faster than.
There today.
I love that, by the way, somebody who doesn't like to shop, the idea that it's actually quicker for me to order it online and have it delivered than it would be for me to get in my car and go get it to go shopping somehow.
It's a big dilemma that we have at home.
I, I think sometimes it's better to go out shopping, but you know, well, that some see shopping as a sport.
I get it.
Uh, that's just not who I am.
Um, but I can see that this is also like one of the effects of COVID, interestingly, that we've totally changed how we view.
These types of services and I think the rise in, you know, um, the, the ride sharing and the food delivery and, uh, and all of the likes is really changing how people can the consumption of some of these goods.
No, no, Mark, we started to talk about some of the downsides, you know, I mentioned noise, uh, as one, that kind of the nuisance factor that these might create.
There are concerns about safety, you know, if one of these starts to drop out of the sky.
Um, privacy, privacy, you know, another one that I don't think we're there yet, but, um, just congestion, like, is this a worry?
Are we gonna have like, look up and all we're gonna see are, you know, hundreds of drones flying over our heads at any point in time?
What, what are your thoughts on some of these challenges?
Are we able to solve some of them?
Um, are they overblown?
Yeah, yeah, um, no, no, I don't think they're, I think they're overblown.
I think they're real challenges, but I do think they're, um, you know, they are solvable with the right amount of, you know, regulation and tech, you know, technological, uh, implementation.
So, I'm gonna start with one that's kind of, uh, that I, that I think about that I don't, um.
Sometimes may get lost in a lot of those, you know, noise and, uh, you know, potential for midair collisions and other concerns, but we, you know, we were just talking about the Uber Eats, DoorDash model and, and what we saw, I think during the pandemic was a lot of um small businesses kind of being forced to sign on, sign up for that model to keep up, basically keep up sales and, you know, one of the big questions with drones, I, you know, I mentioned the similarity, but one big difference is that, um.
You know, you can imagine, uh you mentioned Chipotle, you can imagine Chipotle having the working capital to, you know, install whatever or, you know, reserve space and um design their stores in order to incorporate the space for, uh, you know, for a drone, and I think one of the questions that I think about is, you know, how does a small business, That is a small business, keep up with that and um I think that's a real question of, you know, will they have the capital and the ability to alter whatever sort of, uh, you know, store mechanism it would be to, you know, to deliver that.
So I'll, uh, by the way, I'll start there.
I love that as a strategist, I love that idea that like this question of will this technology cause more concentration, big platforms where everybody has to use the same platform to get their delivery.
Or could it actually have the opposite?
Could it actually empower the small business, the end, you know, retailer to not have to go through a DoorDash or an Uber Eats, and that's fascinating, fascinating.
One of our faculty here that maybe we'll introduce you to Mark, uh, Pina Feldman, she does her work on.
On exactly that, like, what is the cost to those small businesses that the Uber Eats were introduced as an option to expand your market and service people that are at home, but actually with at the end of the day when you look at all the fees and everything, the restaurants lose money, right, right, right, I can, I can see the concern for small businesses, Mark, for sure, yeah, and, and the other downside to that, and I, I can speak to this as you know, I've, I've driven for Uber Eats before, um.
I'm not afraid to admit it.
Um, you know, the, you know, you, you will, you, there, there's job loss there.
Um, yeah, I wouldn't say it was particularly, you know, like, it, it's not like a high-quality job or anything like that, but, you know, there, there is that side of it, you know, too.
Um, but, you know, going back to the, the other thing about, um, or excuse me, your other point about, uh, downsides, is, yeah, certainly, you know, you mentioned before privacy and, um, I, I think of privacy is kind of like one of the and perhaps, you know, my, I'm insensitive to this, but I kind of.
I, I don't really buy the whole privacy argument because if you're gonna get something delivered to your house, um, you know, whether it be via a delivery driver or a ground-based robot or um uh UAV and the thing is either gonna have, you know, eyes, cameras, or, um, You know, something to know where it's going and deliver it.
So, and your name and your address, and your name and your address, exactly.
And you know, at, at that point, it's your, it's your choice whether you'd rather have a human there or a, you know, or maybe it's your choice, maybe you don't have a choice in the future, um, but If you choose to have something delivered to your house, you're basically, in my mind, signing an agreement that, you know, like you, somebody is going to put eyes, something, somebody or something is gonna put eyes on your house and, you know, in order to deliver that.
Package.
So, I mean I could make the argument that it's safer then, right, than hadman who's coming by your house who you don't know and uh that's what I, that's what I'm hearing from Mark Tomington, yeah yeah, yeah, yeah.
So how about the, the noise and the nuisance, uh, part of this?
Yeah, I think this is a real, a real big one for customer, uh, customer adoption and retention in what we.
Uh, zip line has focused their particular system, um, which is kind of like this bigger drone thing, yeah, dropping the smaller what we call a droid at the bottom.
And uh that's designed to keep a lot of the big noise way, way up high, um, or, you know, 200 ft above the house, um, and reduce, reduce that noise because I think noise does end up being a, a real concern.
I mean, People don't want to hear drones flying around all day.
I don't, I, I will admit that I am personally annoyed by, um, you know, when I hear a drone kind of flying around, it, it, it, it's almost an unsettling feeling in me thinking that, you know, somebody's watching me, so, you know, the, they.
I think that Amazon had some problems with this in College Station with one of their earlier designs, and um it had a lot of complaints about um about the noise and uh it being basically perpetually sounding like a hive of bees, um, you know, around people's houses, so, uh.
Yeah, I think, you know, solving the noise factor is going to be a major, a major, um, Wait.
Again, trying to pull out the optimist in me, but like I can imagine one day, maybe not our generation, but you know, shortly after or maybe, you know, an intermediate generation getting some solace from that noise, knowing that somebody's there to help you, meaning like, imagine like you're an elderly in your house on your own and like something happens and you need help, right?
Like there's a way in which this helps us get immediate care to people.
Much sooner, um, and so that you get some, some comfort knowing that the drone is there monitoring you.
I don't know, I, can, can that may be a way to kind of think about where it could go, you know, when we have these technological transitions, uh, we talk about the emergence of a dominant design that often comes as it becomes more, right, yeah, that's a classic, uh. iPhone and things like that, uh, it strikes me that we're still in the predominant design phase with these drone delivery services.
I think zipline is a great example.
It's a novel idea to have the drone up high and then a zipline dropping the, uh, the delivery pod, as you called it, or a droid down you, um, so I, I, I imagine that like some of these problems they'll wrestle through and they'll be.
The dominant design that emerges that addresses them in whatever way society deems is appropriate at the end of the day.
Well, well, Mark, thank you so much for your time and we, we really appreciate your, your insights here.
Such an expert on those dimensions.
Yes, yeah, of course, didn't even get to mention it, but yeah, like, like, obviously lots of regulatory issues and national security implications as well, uh, so.
Um, I'll just, uh, yeah, throw that, um, throw that one out there, throw open that Pandora's box before I leave.
So, uh, thank you so much for having me.
All right, yeah, yeah, where, where do you stand?
Oh, it's a tough one for me.
Um, I say I can see the potentials, but I'm also kind of, uh, if you ask me today, you know, the fall of 2025, not to date, the time that we're recording this episode, um, the weight of the state of the world.
Uh, I can feel it like hanging over me and affecting my, my verdict, right?
The use case for the military and what we're seeing on the defense side concerns me a lot, um, and so while I can see the potential there for it to offer good disruptions right now I'm, I'm a little bit more on the negative side just to push you a little bit on the military application, is it the drone per se or is it the autonomy?
You know, if it was a bunch of autonomous robots who are walking across the field, maybe a humanoid robot, both, I think it's a little bit of both.
I think the, the, the autonomous, um, aspect of it again, that lack of, um, uh, skin in the game, that is an incentive for, for country.
Choose to not engage in warfare, I think is really important and, and, and we're struggling with that, quite frankly turn effect, yeah, like you said, you know, humans at risk, exactly, and the effect on civilians, uh, just far, far, far outstrips, uh, kind of things that we've seen in the past, um.
And so yeah, so right now I can see and you know it's this is not the first time in history where new technology is first embraced by the military and then there's regulation as Mark mentioned that come kicks in and helps us put it, uh, put it to better use and so I'm, I'm excited.
For those days to come, uh, but right now I'm, I'm pretty, pretty nervous.
Yeah, I, I'll start with the commercial side first, and, um, uh, that's where I'm probably more optimistic.
Um, and again, there are these downsides for sure, uh, that we'll need to navigate through, but I think this is actually, as Mark was alluding to, a heavily regulated environment, uh, the airspace and air travel, at least in the United States, um.
And so that that gives me some hope that, you know, this isn't gonna go off the rails where again this future where all we see are drones everywhere.
I, I think we'll, we'll figure that out.
It will co-evolve the, the policy with the technology.
So maybe it's the AI inside the drones that you're more nervous about compared to the actual flight of the drones that is more regulated.
Well, no, I mean, I think it, I think it all works in, in concert with one another, and I think, you know, again, it's not only the use cases of delivery, which Again, I could see some use cases there, um, but again, as I mentioned, like agriculture, energy infrastructure, construction, like all of these areas where having a visual, uh, you know, aerial vision on some project and the like and what that can do to help, um, mixed in with maybe machine learning algorithms to improve operations, uh, that, that seems really appealing to me, uh, and I don't see, I don't see a ton of downsides to that.
Um, and so I, I guess on that side I'm, I'm, I'm definitely pro, uh, or favorable, um, on the military.
I'm, I'm with you.
Like I mean it's, it's a scary world we're moving into, um, already living, and we're already living, living in, and, um, it, you know, I, I don't think it's hyperbolic to say like this is completely changing the nature of warfare, um, and.
Where that ends, and like you said, like, does it remove restraints that we've had on engaging in military conflicts that that is worrisome.
So what's your final verdict?
You have a good, bad, or no?
For the first time, well, maybe not for the first time, but I'm leaning towards the bad right now.
I'm gonna, I'm gonna play the good side.
This is like we've reversed roles from some of the things that we did there, um, but I, I think the points you raise are really, are really valid, and I think, um, I guess it's imperative as, as a, as the human race that we.
Figure out these types of technologies and when they can be deployed and it shouldn't be and organizations like Zipline and the like that are doing a lot of good with it and are being thoughtful and trying to kind of stay ahead of it to, to use it both commercially but also to do the, the, the great use cases.
I think we need a lot of that to counteract it, um, and I'm hoping that, um, we can get our act together.
On the military side too, but right now I'm, I'm seeing a lot of negative.
All right, all right, all right.
Well, again, uh, we wanna thank Mark, our special guest expert, uh, as always, Gary, our producer, Becky, our lead researcher, Katie, our other researcher, you know, we're expanding the team here.
Uh, thank you all and enjoy the rest of your day.
Thank you, Mike.
Good Disruption is a podcast from the University of Virginia Darden School of Business.
Darden.