Why WeWork Didn’t Work as Planned: 4 Lessons on Corporate Governance
Hype vs. discipline. Charisma vs. responsibility. The buzz around Adam Neumann’s WeWork went from enthusiasm for a unicorn with billions in venture capital to backlash for a company with a plummeted valuation and scrapped IPO. Yet with new leadership and governance structures, long-term profit may be in sight. What might we learn from WeWork?
The recent release of WeCrashed, an Apple TV+ miniseries on the WeWork saga, is just one of several new TV series — including Super Pumped, which is about Uber, and The Dropout, about Theranos — that have fueled a fascination with high-profile corporate-governance breakdowns. The opportunity to peer behind the scenes of what happened at these companies has not only piqued the public’s interest, it has also shifted the broader conversation in the investment community around the importance of establishing effective startup governance and guardrails around founder influence.
The Big Idea
WeWork appeared to be destined for great things. From inception, the coworking company had an extraordinary ability to generate buzz among investors, press and media, and in no small part this was down to the charisma of its founder, Adam Neumann. A flamboyant figure prone to eccentricities and etiquette-busting antics, Neumann quickly had investors in thrall — none more so than Japanese conglomerate, SoftBank. So entranced was SoftBank founder, Masayoshi Son, with Neumann’s grandiose ambitions and infectious optimism, that in 2017 he made an initial outlay of $4.4 billion in a deal that valued WeWork at $20 billion.
And the cash only continued to flow. Even as Neumann began to wrest more and more voting power from the board and his eccentricities multiplied, unchecked — giving his wife major corporate responsibilities and trademarking the word “We,” among them — SoftBank eagerly poured another $13 billion into the company over the next two years, coupled with a mandate for growth.
In 2019, all signs were that WeWork was on track for a big-splash IPO, they thought. And a handsome payday for Neumann, Son and SoftBank.
The Scenario
An attempt to list WeWork in 2019 was a disaster. When the company’s pre-IPO registration papers were made public on the Securities and Exchange Commission website in August, it gave external investors and journalists a first, clear look at its financials, its business plan and governance structures. And what they saw did not tally with its stratospheric price tag.
For a start, WeWork’s aggressive pursuit of fast growth was not backed by a long-term roadmap to profitability or a plan to attenuate ballooning costs. Then there was the issue of Neumann’s excessive control over the board, his conflicts of interest, loans he had taken from the business and questionable transactions. Questions were asked about his self-dealing and about the board’s failure to exercise sufficient oversight to rein in their eccentric CEO and keep his voting power in check.
The backlash was immediate. WeWork’s valuation plummeted from $47 billion to just $5 billion, and in fewer than four weeks, the IPO was scrapped. Neumann was ousted as CEO, but only after SoftBank had agreed to a severance payout of $1.8 billion — a gesture that undoubtedly left a sour taste in the mouths of the thousands of WeWork employees whose jobs were also scuttled in the fallout.
For this unicorn, flush with billions in venture capital and tipped to become the next big thing in tech and retail, the dream was over. For SoftBank, the job of recouping its losses was just beginning.
About UVA Darden School of Business
The University of Virginia Darden School of Business prepares responsible global leaders through unparalleled transformational learning experiences.
Darden's graduate degree programs and Executive Education & Lifelong Learning programs offered by the Darden School Foundation set the stage for a lifetime of career advancement and impact.
Press Contact
Molly Mitchell
Senior Associate Director, Editorial and Media Relations
MitchellM@darden.virginia.edu