[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"$f3pnda2tyljdwi":3,"$f1fn4bvlmx2a6v":232,"page-template:\u002Farticles\u002Fdrilling-and-debt:{}":253},{"content":4,"navigationFallbacksEnabled":35,"previewEnvironmentEnabled":35},{"siteKey":5,"siteName":6,"tagline":7,"seo":8,"errorPage":21,"siteModals":36,"customSettings":37,"globals":42},"darden-report","Darden Report","News and knowledge from the UVA Darden School of Business.",{"title":9,"description":10,"image":11},"Darden Report - The Latest News and Ideas from UVA Darden School of Business","The Darden Report offers the latest news, research, and stories about the University of Virginia Darden School of Business.",{"src":12,"alt":13,"aspectRatio":14,"width":15,"height":16,"bynderDat":17},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002F189175de-2440-489a-939e-91d6f7e7989a\u002FGoodwin-Grounds-autumn","goodwin grounds","6048 \u002F 4024",6048,4024,{"baseUrl":18,"assetId":19,"name":20},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu","189175de-2440-489a-939e-91d6f7e7989a","Goodwin-Grounds-autumn",{"statusLabel":22,"title":23,"summaryBeforeHomeLink":24,"homeLinkLabel":25,"homeHref":26,"summaryAfterHomeLink":27,"searchEnabled":28,"searchLabel":29,"searchPlaceholder":30,"seo":31},"Error 404","Wa-who?","We cannot locate a page at this address. Try searching using the input below or starting from the ","homepage","\u002F",".",true,"Search Darden Report","Search...",{"title":32,"description":33,"robots":34},"Page Not Found",null,{"noindex":28,"nofollow":35},false,[],{"algoliaEngagement":38},{"activeSeconds":39,"scrollRatio":40,"idleSeconds":41,"mediaPercent":39},20,0.5,60,{"masthead":43,"menuOverlay":59,"footer":191},{"homeHref":26,"tagline":7,"topicsLabel":44,"subscribeLabel":45,"menuLabel":46,"searchLabel":47,"topics":48},"Trending","Subscribe","Open menu","Open search",[49,51,53,55,57],{"label":50,"href":26},"Tariffs Q&A",{"label":52,"href":26},"AI Datacenters",{"label":54,"href":26},"Productivity Boom",{"label":56,"href":26},"CES 2026",{"label":58,"href":26},"Colorado Water Rights",{"overlayLabel":60,"homeHref":26,"tagline":7,"quickLinks":61,"topicsLabel":62,"topics":63,"browseLabel":121,"browseLinks":122,"connectLabel":154,"connectLinks":155,"registerLabel":172,"registerCta":173,"searchLabel":29,"searchPlaceholder":30,"searchSubmitLabel":189,"closeLabel":190},"Site menu",[],"Topics",[64,71,77,83,89,95,102,109,115],{"id":65,"label":66,"href":67,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35,"description":68,"imageSrc":69,"imageAlt":70},"2PGBfQ54OTbNUe92lTxC30","Artificial Intelligence","\u002Ftopics\u002Fartificial-intelligence","Research and expert perspective on intelligent systems, automation, and the changing economics of decision-making. Darden faculty explore how organizations can evaluate emerging tools, govern responsible adoption, and use AI to improve judgment, productivity, customer value, and competitive advantage without losing sight of people and institutional trust.","https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fsquare-medium\u002Feadee323-faa1-436f-979b-40761fb64624\u002FAI-Primary-Topic-Vertical","Surreal AI-Generated Cosmic Landscape – Generative AI, Art and Human Creativity",{"id":72,"label":73,"href":74,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35,"description":75,"imageSrc":76,"imageAlt":73},"7hvQgsg6I0A9QRkXKcNJrN","Data & Analytics","\u002Ftopics\u002Fdata-analytics","Data & Analysis examines how leaders turn information into sharper questions, stronger evidence, and better decisions. Darden insights cover analytics, experimentation, forecasting, risk, and interpretation, helping organizations separate signal from noise and translate complex findings into practical choices across strategy, operations, markets, and society.","https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fsquare-medium\u002Fbbea14b9-cfe3-415b-bcab-f97f753f6c54\u002FData-Analytics-Primary-Topic",{"id":78,"label":79,"href":80,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35,"description":81,"imageSrc":82,"imageAlt":79},"7hztN5kb1RdsP9iGiC05dV","Entrepreneurship","\u002Ftopics\u002Fentrepreneurship","Economic and social advancement require leaders who embrace an entrepreneurial outlook and a commitment to innovation. Darden thought leadership emphasizes that an entrepreneurial mindset is about more than starting a new business venture; it encompasses the opportunity-seizing and action-oriented behavior essential for sustained growth in organizations of all sizes.","https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fsquare-medium\u002Fa8e8e5fe-f1d5-478b-8877-31b8b0c43f0c\u002FThe-Importance-of-Courage",{"id":84,"label":85,"href":86,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35,"description":87,"imageSrc":88,"imageAlt":85},"2dPcCN1FQ26ZIFcvdIsh4","Global Economies & Markets","\u002Ftopics\u002Fglobal-economies-markets","Faculty insight on trade, markets, policy, global business, and economic change. This topic connects macroeconomic forces with organizational decisions, examining how leaders navigate uncertainty, regulation, capital flows, geopolitical shifts, and cross-border opportunity while building resilient institutions in markets that are increasingly interdependent.","https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fsquare-medium\u002Fd6db5e0d-c0fe-4e51-8f38-5e995d232d04\u002FA-Quick-Queue-or-a-Long-One-Waiting-in-Line-Around-the-World",{"id":90,"label":91,"href":92,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35,"description":93,"imageSrc":94,"imageAlt":91},"7mgp2vBjTofDsgB34ap4nb","Ethics & Society","\u002Ftopics\u002Fbusiness-ethics-society","The multidisciplinary study of Business, Ethics & Society focuses on sustaining, growing and sharing value, not just for businesses and their shareholders, but for stakeholders and the societies in which they operate. This vein of study encompasses ethical decision-making, examination of how business can and does impact society, implications for policy, principles of moral and institutional leadership, and the tenets of stakeholder theory.","https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fsquare-medium\u002F326ec289-e377-49ca-81ff-8a78a16d7e6d\u002FEthics-and-Society-Primary-Topic",{"id":96,"label":97,"href":98,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35,"description":99,"imageSrc":100,"imageAlt":101},"18nXfYyrV3JAT3y57GWhcK","Leadership & Management","\u002Ftopics\u002Fleadership-management","Practical research for leading teams, organizations, culture, and change. Darden thought leadership explores how managers build trust, make difficult decisions, communicate purpose, develop talent, and guide people through uncertainty while sustaining performance and strengthening the human systems that make organizations work.","https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fsquare-medium\u002F6557a226-8bac-44d0-83c1-0efdfe88b396\u002F11-Key-Characteristics-of-a-Global-Business-Leader","various colors of blocks stand in an equality and inclusive space, in the style of precisionism influence, silhouette figures, superimposed text, nul group, disfigured forms, miniature illumination, consumer culture critique --ar 128:85 --stylize 50 --v 6 Job ID: 2731b55d-e2b8-4468-81be-bb16e507686f",{"id":103,"label":104,"href":105,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35,"description":106,"imageSrc":107,"imageAlt":108},"5JMdm6cuNXm8p9L15kOLSX","Marketing & Sales","\u002Ftopics\u002Fmarketing-sales","Ideas for understanding customers, building markets, and communicating value. This topic examines consumer behavior, brand strategy, sales effectiveness, pricing, segmentation, and digital channels, helping leaders connect insight to action and create relationships that support growth across changing audiences and competitive environments.","https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fsquare-medium\u002F146f2b70-b04a-4495-853d-c5b78196f276\u002FMarketing-Primary-Topic","Marketing Primary Topic",{"id":110,"label":111,"href":112,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35,"description":113,"imageSrc":114,"imageAlt":111},"siVfdjcE5Xfd4pbT1jeWD","Operations & Technology","\u002Ftopics\u002Foperations-technology","Research on systems, digital operations, supply chains, and technology-enabled performance. Darden faculty examine how organizations design processes, manage complexity, improve reliability, and use new tools to create efficient, adaptable operations that support strategy, customer experience, and long-term organizational resilience.","https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fsquare-medium\u002Ff36239ad-c7bf-46fe-93b2-e6df18cb2fef\u002FOperations-Technology-Primary-Topic",{"id":116,"label":117,"href":118,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35,"description":119,"imageSrc":120,"imageAlt":117},"4NDEiXoxAt8TlDGLBWYCqu","Strategy","\u002Ftopics\u002Fstrategy","Frameworks and evidence for competition, growth, transformation, and long-term enterprise decisions. Strategy insights from Darden help leaders assess where to play, how to win, when to change course, and how to allocate resources in ways that create durable advantage amid uncertainty.","https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fsquare-medium\u002Ff8c81a7f-2b2c-4d37-964e-84382b3b1ef5\u002FBeyond-Strategy-3-Lessons-and-4-Ingredients-of-Execution","Browse",[123,127,131,135,139,143,146,150],{"id":124,"label":125,"href":126,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"49UXns6sWSYS1QfelJsnUS","Articles","\u002Farticles",{"id":128,"label":129,"href":130,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"5h02IsSCwqwqdvAeEfC2uq","Podcasts","\u002Fpodcasts",{"id":132,"label":133,"href":134,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"3i2eJKSFhZolFdIe3c6t5V","Videos","\u002Fvideos",{"id":136,"label":137,"href":138,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"7x4aolsVH0DQFMby9iunAJ","Media Features","\u002Fmedia-features",{"id":140,"label":141,"href":142,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"3rM0mhH3WJY4ThjFiyfnoV","Experts","\u002Fexpert\u002Fdirectory",{"id":144,"label":45,"href":145,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"1pq8d8gTugtnM0goPxBXVR","#subscribe",{"id":147,"label":148,"href":149,"external":28,"openInNewWindow":28},"2G9kuRukBaUj9ddCJur1rC","Give","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.givecampus.com\u002Fcampaigns\u002F20048\u002Fdonations\u002Fnew",{"id":151,"label":152,"href":153,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"1ql3y6NAQuUglXnn3dKJPy","About","\u002Fabout","Connect with Darden",[156,160,164,168],{"id":157,"label":158,"href":159,"external":28,"openInNewWindow":28},"2EPrW3IELdCZUN4AdZc5aU","Facebook","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.facebook.com\u002FDardenMBA",{"id":161,"label":162,"href":163,"external":28,"openInNewWindow":28},"382CfbeZQiqklJrRmCGew4","Instagram","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.instagram.com\u002Fdardenmba\u002F",{"id":165,"label":166,"href":167,"external":28,"openInNewWindow":28},"5IPd9qziZHiSSLmZ9ypypW","LinkedIn","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.linkedin.com\u002Fedu\u002Fschool?id=19605",{"id":169,"label":170,"href":171,"external":28,"openInNewWindow":28},"5DpGLgbQS541wvmzk7yAn4","YouTube","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.youtube.com\u002Fuser\u002FDardenMBA","Featured Event",{"id":174,"previewOnly":35,"href":175,"external":28,"accessibleLabel":176,"openInNewWindow":28,"image":177,"date":186,"startDateTime":187,"endDateTime":188,"title":179},"3sGe8qongAY1Kc95z4h0Oh","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.darden.virginia.edu\u002Fexecutive-education\u002Fstrategic-data-analytics-for-competitive-advantage","Test",{"src":178,"alt":179,"aspectRatio":180,"width":181,"height":181,"bynderDat":182},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fsquare-medium\u002Fc9667467-ef6d-41ff-91ee-3f9665adc4b7\u002FDriving-Ethical-Innovation-in-the-Age-of-AI","AI-Powered Data Analytics","1 \u002F 1",700,{"baseUrl":18,"assetId":183,"name":184,"preset":185},"c9667467-ef6d-41ff-91ee-3f9665adc4b7","Driving-Ethical-Innovation-in-the-Age-of-AI","square-medium","Nov 10-13","2026-11-10","2026-11-13","Submit search","Close menu",{"homeHref":26,"links":192,"subscribeHeading":227,"subscribeLabel":45,"imageSrc":228,"imageAlt":229,"institutionalLabel":230,"copyright":231},[193,197,201,204,207,211,214,217,219,223],{"id":194,"label":195,"href":196,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"6GCwvduoNlDEeO6nq1laFq","For The Media","\u002Ffor-the-media",{"id":198,"label":199,"href":200,"external":28,"openInNewWindow":28},"2lqtlsCRCghroHk8jgcCi0","Publications","https:\u002F\u002Fstore.darden.virginia.edu\u002F",{"id":202,"label":203,"href":26,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"4rcubVXgLnQBYxJ833G7DO","Press Releases",{"id":205,"label":206,"href":26,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"6ColvvcR2M2zggiQQ0l965","In the Media",{"id":208,"label":209,"href":210,"external":28,"openInNewWindow":28},"61sOurYMjR8U4mU5omcUjP","Apply to Darden","https:\u002F\u002Fapply.darden.virginia.edu\u002Fapply\u002F",{"id":212,"label":213,"href":149,"external":28,"openInNewWindow":28},"563xnF7I5F2UYWYwJc5eXE","Support Darden",{"id":215,"label":216,"href":153,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"2BySyFumqkDGPDVmTtMYai","Contact Us",{"id":218,"label":152,"href":153,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"4QSVOSvmRnltRwfr5rLoSS",{"id":220,"label":221,"href":222,"external":28,"openInNewWindow":28},"75C0Q1ojWWmESgYLsm9bQk","Privacy Policy","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.darden.virginia.edu\u002Fprivacy-policy-copyright",{"id":224,"label":225,"href":226,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"35rcom3AAkYzApoNSavl1g","Search Darden","\u002Fsearch","Get Darden news, research, and thought leadership in your inbox.","\u002Fimages\u002Fdarden-report-footer.png","Autumn foliage over a brick courtyard at the UVA Darden School of Business.","UVA Darden School of Business","Copyright ©2026 The Rector and Visitors Of The University Of Virginia. All Rights Reserved.",{"enabled":28,"complete":28,"capacity":233,"label":44,"stale":35,"items":234},4,[235,241,245,249],{"contentId":236,"contentType":237,"label":238,"href":239,"source":240},"6MHbMLocipfho9cm5jLxHM","article","AI Economic Impact by 2030","\u002Farticles\u002Fthe-economic-scenarios-of-transformative-ai-a-wide-range-of-possibilities-for-jobs-and-gdp-by-2030","algolia",{"contentId":242,"contentType":237,"label":243,"href":244,"source":240},"5QtyLWjq3hauPenG5pGTED","Alumni Career Advice","\u002Farticles\u002Fin-uva-dardens-classroom-building-six-alumni-put-career-advice-on-the-wall",{"contentId":246,"contentType":237,"label":247,"href":248,"source":240},"23Pz69HrBYAP3sxJeeaNpU","Hiba Anwar’s Fellowship","\u002Farticles\u002Fhiba-anwar-freeland-franklin-fellowship",{"contentId":250,"contentType":237,"label":251,"href":252,"source":240},"2GBmzAadCKzwTWJggqmArB","Christopher Fuller Named CMCO","\u002Farticles\u002Fchristopher-fuller-named-chief-marketing-and-communications-officer-at-uva-darden",{"path":254,"template":255,"content":256,"context":551},"\u002Farticles\u002Fdrilling-and-debt","articlePage",{"id":257,"title":258,"slug":259,"path":254,"modifiedAt":260,"summary":261,"publishedDate":266,"topics":269,"authors":276,"insightsFrom":277,"topper":303,"bodyBlocks":316,"outro":495,"seo":544},"1ldD1gxrZjbEmQOfyl74Mj","Drilling and Debt: When Oil Production Doesn’t Respond to Demand","drilling-and-debt","2026-09-23T12:21:55.985Z",{"plainText":262,"inlines":263},"Why would oil producers continue to pump oil despite an excess supply globally and a shortage in storage space? Darden Professors Elena Loutskina and Daniel Murphy examine how oil prices went negative (and could again), collateralized debt and oil producers’ relationships with lenders, and broader implications for the oil market.",[264],{"type":265,"value":262},"text",{"display":267,"dateTime":268},"10 November 2020","2020-11-10",[270,274],{"id":271,"label":272,"href":273},"finance-investing","Finance & Investing","\u002Ftopics\u002Ffinance-investing",{"id":275,"label":85,"href":86},"global-economies-markets",[],[278,291],{"id":279,"name":280,"title":281,"href":282,"profileType":283,"image":284,"bio":290},"5fNCR8KJiJ7JV8Uszy0Qzp","Elena Loutskina","Professor of Business Administration, Peter M. Grant II Bicentennial Foundation Chair in Business Administration, Academic Director of Richard A. Mayo Center for Asset Management","\u002Fexpert\u002Fdirectory\u002Felena-loutskina","faculty",{"src":285,"alt":286,"aspectRatio":180,"width":181,"height":181,"bynderDat":287},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fsquare-medium\u002Fe45e2ab5-51f2-4bf5-b3e8-15ec39f01f4e\u002FElena-Loutskina-Preferred","Elena Loutskina Preferred",{"baseUrl":18,"assetId":288,"name":289,"preset":185},"e45e2ab5-51f2-4bf5-b3e8-15ec39f01f4e","Elena-Loutskina-Preferred","Loutskina is an authority on banking and securitization. She researches corporate financing, venture capital and innovation, and earnings management. Her primary focus is the impact of securitization markets on financial management of corporations.",{"id":292,"name":293,"title":294,"href":295,"profileType":283,"image":296,"bio":302},"2RUvpsTovSF77aI6AfGGQC","Daniel Murphy","Jung Family Associate Professor of Business Administration","\u002Fexpert\u002Fdirectory\u002Fdaniel-murphy",{"src":297,"alt":298,"aspectRatio":180,"width":181,"height":181,"bynderDat":299},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fsquare-medium\u002F04f2e7b6-e3f0-498f-a521-69130e281daf\u002FDan-Murphy-Preferred","Dan Murphy Preferred",{"baseUrl":18,"assetId":300,"name":301,"preset":185},"04f2e7b6-e3f0-498f-a521-69130e281daf","Dan-Murphy-Preferred","Murphy researches the nature of consumer demand and its implications for market outcomes. His work addresses economic and policy issues including the determinants of cross-country price differences and the consequences of asymmetric economic growth.",{"id":304,"variant":305,"title":258,"subheadline":33,"topic":306,"image":307},"1ldD1gxrZjbEmQOfyl74Mj-topper","tall",{"id":271,"label":272,"href":273},{"src":308,"alt":309,"aspectRatio":310,"width":311,"height":312,"bynderDat":313},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fefc56c5d-77ce-45cc-9d8a-9b7d429788aa\u002FDrilling-and-Debt-When-Oil-Production-Doesn-t-Respond-to-Demand","Graphic of gasoline can.","3 \u002F 4",900,1200,{"baseUrl":18,"assetId":314,"name":315},"efc56c5d-77ce-45cc-9d8a-9b7d429788aa","Drilling-and-Debt-When-Oil-Production-Doesn-t-Respond-to-Demand",[317],{"id":318,"contentType":319,"region":320,"render":321},"1ldD1gxrZjbEmQOfyl74Mj-body-0","richText","body",{"component":322,"props":323},"RichTextBlock",{"content":324},{"blocks":325},[326,347,359,364,372,377,382,387,393,398,422,427,432,437,442,448,453,484],{"type":327,"content":328},"paragraph",[329,332,337,340,344],{"type":265,"value":330,"marks":331},"On 20 April 2020, something unprecedented happened: ",[],{"type":333,"value":334,"href":335,"external":28,"marks":336},"link","Oil prices went negative","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.npr.org\u002Fsections\u002Fcoronavirus-live-updates\u002F2020\u002F04\u002F20\u002F838521862\u002Ffree-falling-oil-prices-keep-diving-as-demand-disappears",[],{"type":265,"value":338,"marks":339},". While oil prices had been trading low for weeks, reduced demand from a country on stay-at-home orders, combined with other factors, forced investors to ",[],{"type":265,"value":341,"marks":342},"pay people to take delivery of oil",[343],"italic",{"type":265,"value":345,"marks":346},", rather than reaping their anticipated profit. ",[],{"type":327,"content":348},[349,352,356],{"type":265,"value":350,"marks":351},"Negative oil prices constitute as dire an issue for oil producers as it sounds: This was the first time the U.S. had seen negative oil prices. Prices did rebound by the end of the day on 20 April, but with the global market awash in excess oil and storage space in short supply, a negative dip in prices could happen again. ",[],{"type":333,"value":353,"href":354,"external":28,"marks":355},"Julian Lee","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.washingtonpost.com\u002Fbusiness\u002Fenergy\u002Fnegative-oil-prices-were-a-warning-not-an-anomaly\u002F2020\u002F04\u002F26\u002F4691ce94-8783-11ea-81a3-9690c9881111_story.html",[],{"type":265,"value":357,"marks":358},", an oil strategist for Bloomberg, described the situation this way: “Unless producers start cutting supply much more aggressively [than they already are], another bout of negative prices will have to jolt them into action.” ",[],{"type":327,"content":360},[361],{"type":265,"value":362,"marks":363},"However, cutting production might not be as simple as it sounds. Two Darden professors, Elena Loutskina and Daniel Murphy, explain why oil producers might continue to pump oil, despite the current conditions. ",[],{"type":365,"id":366,"level":367,"content":368},"heading","what-happens-to-production-when-oil-prices-drop",2,[369],{"type":265,"value":370,"marks":371},"What Happens to Production When Oil Prices Drop?",[],{"type":327,"content":373},[374],{"type":265,"value":375,"marks":376},"While the negative oil prices of 20 April are unprecedented, dramatic changes in demand and price are not. In 2014, oil prices in the United States plummeted from over $100 a barrel in June to half of that by the end of the year. But the low oil price was not expected to last. As of late 2014, six-month futures prices (the price of an oil contract to deliver oil six months in the future) were 15 percent higher than the current spot price of oil, suggesting that oil prices were expected to rise again.",[],{"type":327,"content":378},[379],{"type":265,"value":380,"marks":381},"In the United States, most oil production comes from shale oil and is extracted through hydraulic fracturing, or fracking. Each fracking well produces oil for a relatively short period of time (two to three years), and the greatest value of the well is typically extracted within the first year. This means that if an oil and gas company wants to reduce its production volume, it can delay opening new fracking wells. In June 2014, these companies faced declining oil prices along with very lucrative futures prices. Thus, delaying the opening of new wells almost guaranteed higher prices in the future.",[],{"type":327,"content":383},[384],{"type":265,"value":385,"marks":386},"Unsurprisingly, the majority of producers chose to delay initiating new production by three months on average. After all, holding oil in the ground is the cheapest way to store it. But what was surprising is that not all firms followed suit. A group of oil producers maintained high oil production even in the face of expected oil price appreciation. As a result, the oil production did not decline dramatically, and oil prices lingered at the much lower level for another year.",[],{"type":365,"id":388,"level":367,"content":389},"but-why-continue-to-produce",[390],{"type":265,"value":391,"marks":392},"But Why Continue to Produce?",[],{"type":327,"content":394},[395],{"type":265,"value":396,"marks":397},"Why would some oil producers continue production when it would be more profitable to delay? A one-month delay in opening a fracking well mid-2014 could have brought about a 4.8 percent increase per project. That would have amounted to an estimated $124,000 in net present value at the time — that is, the additional money it would later have brought in, adjusted for mid-2014.",[],{"type":327,"content":399},[400,403,406,409,412,415,419],{"type":265,"value":401,"marks":402},"To answer this question, Darden Professors ",[],{"type":333,"value":280,"href":404,"external":28,"marks":405},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ffaculty-research\u002Fdirectory\u002Felena-loutskina",[],{"type":265,"value":407,"marks":408}," and ",[],{"type":333,"value":293,"href":410,"external":28,"marks":411},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ffaculty-research\u002Fdirectory\u002Fdaniel-murphy",[],{"type":265,"value":413,"marks":414},", along with their co-author ",[],{"type":333,"value":416,"href":417,"external":28,"marks":418},"Erik Gilje","https:\u002F\u002Ffnce.wharton.upenn.edu\u002Fprofile\u002Fgilje\u002F#research",[],{"type":265,"value":420,"marks":421},", explored the role of oil producers’ contracts with bank lenders based on the notion that high-debt borrowers were the most likely to need to utilize bank lines of credit. They show that producers that continued pumping oil were primarily those with high levels of debt. ",[],{"type":327,"content":423},[424],{"type":265,"value":425,"marks":426},"Why would the companies make such decisions? The answer is tied to how firms finance the expansion of their operations: collateralized debt. Collateral is a great tool that helps creditors manage their credit risk exposure and aids borrowers in lowering their cost of debt. For oil producers, collateral is the underground oil that can be extracted and sold. The more certainty the lender has about the quality of the collateral, the better credit conditions it can offer to the borrower. As oil wells move from geological survey, to pre-drilling, to drilled status, to fracked status, banks assign higher collateral values to the reserves this well represents. ",[],{"type":327,"content":428},[429],{"type":265,"value":430,"marks":431},"Loutskina and Murphy found that high-debt oil producers tended to continue producing oil when they needed to demonstrate their collateral values and expand their access to credit, despite the low price. Companies accelerated new well openings just before they renegotiated their debt contract with lenders. Specifically, they opened high-volume well or wells that provided the lender with the most information about the firm’s other shale reserves. These actions improved the collateral values assigned by the lender and lowered the borrower’s cost for existing and new debt. Bottom line, these highly-leveraged oil and gas firms were forgoing high revenues on their oil production to lower their cost of debt.",[],{"type":327,"content":433},[434],{"type":265,"value":435,"marks":436},"Banks encourage this behavior because it reduces their risk. If banks were fully informed about the quality of the oil reserves their borrowers held underground, then banks and oil-producing borrowers could renegotiate their contracts so that lenders and borrowers could all benefit from the future expected rise of the price of oil. But banks do not always know whether their clients are creditworthy or would act in the best interest of the lender. Collateral acts as a binding mechanism to force borrowers to act prudently.",[],{"type":327,"content":438},[439],{"type":265,"value":440,"marks":441},"Loutskina and Murphy show that the relationship between oil producers and lenders can have an important impact on the oil market. A drop in the price of oil should signal to oil producers to reduce extraction. However, when high-debt oil producers need to demonstrate their capacity to produce oil, in order to reassure their lender, the need to access capital on favorable terms overrides the signals from the larger oil market.",[],{"type":365,"id":443,"level":367,"content":444},"broader-implications-for-the-oil-market",[445],{"type":265,"value":446,"marks":447},"Broader Implications for the Oil Market",[],{"type":327,"content":449},[450],{"type":265,"value":451,"marks":452},"Loutskina and Murphy offer several implications of this research for the current oil market. ",[],{"type":454,"items":455},"unorderedList",[456,463,470,477],{"blocks":457},[458],{"type":327,"content":459},[460],{"type":265,"value":461,"marks":462},"Global oil market dynamics are often considered dependent on the interaction of global demand with the production technologies of oil producers. However, firm-level characteristics such as lending relationships can have an impact on oil supply and therefore on the global oil market.",[],{"blocks":464},[465],{"type":327,"content":466},[467],{"type":265,"value":468,"marks":469},"Lenders to oil producers might want to plan to relax collateral requirements during periods of low (but increasing) oil prices. Producing oil when the price is low is value-destroying for the oil producer (and therefore is detrimental to their lending partners).",[],{"blocks":471},[472],{"type":327,"content":473},[474],{"type":265,"value":475,"marks":476},"Oil investors should consider the average level of debt within the industry before making investment decisions. A higher level of average debt could signal a reluctance on the part of oil companies to reduce production when faced with reduced demand.",[],{"blocks":478},[479],{"type":327,"content":480},[481],{"type":265,"value":482,"marks":483},"Finally, if oil demand stays low and storage capacity for extracted oil remains limited, high-debt companies may struggle to access the credit necessary to survive, which could lead to restructuring within the oil industry.",[],{"type":327,"content":485},[486,489,492],{"type":265,"value":487,"marks":488},"Elena Loutskina and Daniel Murphy co-authored “Drilling and Debt,” which appeared in",[343],{"type":265,"value":490,"marks":491}," The Journal of Finance, ",[],{"type":265,"value":493,"marks":494},"with Erik P. Gilje of the University of Pennsylvania Wharton School.",[343],{"tags":496,"pressContact":502,"bios":532},{"topics":497,"storyType":500},[498,499],{"id":271,"label":272,"href":273},{"id":275,"label":85,"href":86},{"label":501,"href":126},"Article",{"id":503,"heading":504,"body":505,"image":515,"action":523,"contactLabel":525,"contactId":526,"contactName":527,"contactTitle":528,"contactEmail":529},"1JXqEbL3azVV5umnM8ChNj","About UVA Darden School of Business",{"blocks":506},[507,511],{"type":327,"content":508},[509],{"type":265,"value":510},"The University of Virginia Darden School of Business prepares responsible global leaders through unparalleled transformational learning experiences.",{"type":327,"content":512},[513],{"type":265,"value":514},"Darden's graduate degree programs and Executive Education & Lifelong Learning programs offered by the Darden School Foundation set the stage for a lifetime of career advancement and impact.",{"src":516,"alt":517,"aspectRatio":518,"width":519,"height":520,"bynderDat":521},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fc88de114-fc91-4aa8-b801-2e987f7a4a22\u002FDarden_Spring_Environmental_Spring_25_Saunders_Hall_20","Darden_Spring_Environmental_Spring_25_Saunders_Hall_20","8354 \u002F 5569",8354,5569,{"baseUrl":18,"assetId":522,"name":517},"c88de114-fc91-4aa8-b801-2e987f7a4a22",{"label":524,"href":26,"external":35,"openInNewWindow":35},"Learn More","Press Contact","2KGmVfjHQigGuWjTI4aCKw","Lauren Foster","Senor Director of Communications",{"label":530,"href":531},"fosterl@darden.virginia.edu","mailto:fosterl@darden.virginia.edu",[533,539],{"id":279,"name":280,"title":281,"body":290,"image":534,"action":536},{"src":285,"alt":286,"aspectRatio":180,"width":181,"height":181,"bynderDat":535},{"baseUrl":18,"assetId":288,"name":289,"preset":185},{"label":537,"href":282,"accessibleLabel":538},"Read more","Read more about Elena Loutskina",{"id":292,"name":293,"title":294,"body":302,"image":540,"action":542},{"src":297,"alt":298,"aspectRatio":180,"width":181,"height":181,"bynderDat":541},{"baseUrl":18,"assetId":300,"name":301,"preset":185},{"label":537,"href":295,"accessibleLabel":543},"Read more about Daniel Murphy",{"title":258,"description":262,"image":545},{"src":546,"alt":309,"aspectRatio":547,"width":312,"height":548,"bynderDat":549},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.darden.virginia.edu\u002Ftransform\u002Fwidescreen-large\u002Fefc56c5d-77ce-45cc-9d8a-9b7d429788aa\u002FDrilling-and-Debt-When-Oil-Production-Doesn-t-Respond-to-Demand?io=transform%3Afill%2Cwidth%3A1200%2Cheight%3A630&quality=75","1200 \u002F 630",630,{"baseUrl":18,"assetId":314,"name":315,"preset":550},"widescreen-large",{"canonicalPath":254,"identity":552},{"id":257,"contentType":237,"title":258,"path":254,"publishedAt":268,"modifiedAt":260,"topics":553,"authors":556,"eligibility":557},[554,555],{"id":271,"label":272},{"id":275,"label":85},[],{"searchEngines":28,"followLinks":28,"internalSearch":28}]